First American Home Warranty vs American Home Shield

First American Home Warranty vs American Home Shield

First American Home Warranty vs American Home Shield

Let’s do a First American Home Warranty vs American Home Shield comparison. Here’s a quick comparative table and a fully detailed comparison.

Select Home Warranty

American Home Shield

PLANS

  • Systems Plan

  • Appliances Plan

  • Combo Plan (systems + appliances)

  • Build Your Own Plan

  • Bronze (6 systems)

  • Gold (8 appliances)

  • Platinum (bronze + gold + garage + plumbing)

COST

Cost vary per plan. They are considered more affordable than competition.

Cost vary per plan. They are considered more expensive than competition.

NOTABLE PROS

All technicians and contractors are licensed. Can send service worker within 2 business days.

Founded in 1971, has over 15000 service technicians.

OVERALL RATING BY CUSTOMERS

AHS was founded in 1971. Indeed it happens to be the oldest home service contract company.

Furthermore it has paid more than $1 billion in home warranty claims since 2012.

Its competitor FAHW charges extra for air conditioning services.

At the same time, it offers some unique services that other companies don’t.

Therefore, let’s start the First American Home Warranty vs American Home Shield comparison.

First American Home Warranty

Currently, FAHW serves 34 states. This includes the District of Columbia. It has approximately 590,000 customers.

The company states that nearly two-thirds of its customers file at least one complaint each year.

Furthermore, FAHW offers a Basic and Premier home warranty plan.

Neither of these plans offer standard air conditioning coverage. However, you can enhance any plan with a First Class Upgrade Package. This package will indeed grant you extra coverage.

Unlike some of its competitors, FAHW does not offer leak coverage. 

American Home Shield Warranty

American Home Shield Warranty serves all 50 states except Alaska. It employs 15,000 service technicians.

Furthermore, AHS has handled over 65 million service requests.

As compared to other companies, AHS offers a unique opportunity to customize your coverage. This indeeds allows customers to build their own plans .

Plumbing ServicesFirst American Home Warranty vs American Home Shield

FAHW offers plumbing coverage with stoppages only in its Premier Plan.

The coverage includes whirlpool bath motor, air switch assemblies, and pumps, etc.

Furthermore, there are several industry-standard exclusions as well, such as shower-head, faucets, and caulking, etc.

AHS, on the other hand, also covers plumbing systems with stoppages.

It also covers breaks and leaks in gas, water, and vent lines. In addition, it covers shower-heads, faucets, and shower arms.

Electrical Services

FAHW includes junction boxes, electrical wiring, and plugs, etc. In addition to that, it will also replace or repair panels, circuit breakers, and subpanels.

However, it does not cover audio/video equipment, doorbells, and intercoms or alarms, etc. 

AHS on the other hand also provides electrical system coverage in its Combo, Systems, and Build Your Own Plan.

It will repair or replace all components and parts including lighting fixtures, current wiring, and built-in exhaust, etc.

HVAC Services

FAHW covers heating and ductwork. However, air conditioning is part of the First Class Upgrade package for an extra $9 per month.

Additionally, there are many exclusions as well such as improperly sized ductwork, registers, and grills, etc.

American Home Shield on the other hand provides HVAC services in its Combo, Systems, and Build Your Own Plans.

When it comes to heating, it does not cover fuel storage tanks, underground piping, or portable units.

Final Word of First American Home Warranty vs American Home Shield

Although AHS provides comprehensive coverage in the entire USA, it does not in Alaska. Furthermore, it does not allow you to choose the technician of your choice. 

FAHW serves all the states and has no caps on cooling, heating, and ductwork.

Considering the pros and cons, the American Home Shield comes out to be the winner primarily due to the majority of customers putting in their trust in their coverage and services.